The 5 Best Bivy Sacks of 2024 – Outdoor Gear Lab

Welcome, adventurers, to our ultimate guide on the best bivy sacks of 2024! Whether you’re a seasoned mountaineer or a weekend warrior, a good bivy sack can make or break your outdoor experience. Today, we’re diving into the top 5 bivy sacks that have stood out in our rigorous testing. From weather resistance to comfort and packability, we’ve got you covered. So, grab your gear and let’s embark on this exciting journey together!

Your Ultimate Guide to the Best Bivy Sacks for Every Adventure

Imagine a scene straight out of a nature enthusiast’s dream: a solitary bivy sack nestled in the heart of a lush valley, the thin fabric the only barrier between the camper and the breathtaking panorama that unfolds around them.

The bivy sack lies on a soft bed of moss, surrounded by towering pines and craggy peaks bathed in the silver glow of a full moon. A nearby stream babbles gently, its crystal-clear waters reflecting the constellations above. The scene is a symphony of nature’s finest elements, a testament to the beauty of the great outdoors. The bivy sack, humble as it may be, serves as a sanctuary amidst this grandeur, offering a unique perspective on the world for those adventurous enough to inhabit it.

Best Overall Bivy Sack

The Outdoor Research Helium Bivy is a standout in the realm of lightweight, weather-resistant shelters, designed for minimalist adventurers seeking reliable protection from the elements. Its most notable feature is its exceptional weather resistance. Constructed from 30D ripstop nylon with a Pertex Shield+ coating, it boasts impressive hydrostatic head ratings, ensuring you stay dry even in heavy downpours. The fully taped seams and waterproof zipper further enhance its waterproofing capabilities. However, while it excels in rain, its breathability could be better. In humid conditions, condensation can build up inside, leaving you slightly damp.

In terms of weight and packed size, the Helium Bivy is a clear winner. Weighing a mere 17.6 oz (499 g), it’s one of the lightest bivy sacks on the market. It packs down to roughly the size of a 1L Nalgene bottle, making it an excellent choice for fastpackers, thru-hikers, and anyone else looking to shave grams and save space. That being said, the lightweight materials can feel somewhat delicate, and there have been reports of punctures and tears after extended use on rough surfaces.

The Helium Bivy offers a surprising level of comfort and ventilation for a minimalist shelter. The zippered mesh panel at the head allows for adequate airflow on warmer nights, while the flexible Delrin pole creates a small canopy to keep the fabric off your face. However, the comfort comes with a caveat: the narrow, tapered design can feel constricting for larger individuals or those who toss and turn at night. Additionally, the lack of an integrated bug net can be a deal-breaker for those traveling in insect-dense areas. Despite these drawbacks, the Helium Bivy’s combination of low weight, small packed size, and robust weather protection makes it the best overall choice for three-season adventures where every gram counts.

Best Bang for Your Buck

The Katabatic Gear Piñon Bivy has sparked significant interest among outdoor enthusiasts, thanks to its featherlight design, with the entire setup weighing a mere 8.1 ounces (230 grams). The bivy’s lightweight nature is attributable to its 15D nylon ripstop fabric, which offers reasonable durability without adding excessive heft to your pack. Comfort is a strong suit of the Piñon, featuring a roomy shoulder width of 78 inches and a length of 86 inches, providing ample space for most users. Ventilation is addressed through strategically placed vents and its air-permeable fabric, reducing the risk of condensation buildup—a common bane of bivy sacks. Moreover, the Piñon is refreshingly affordable, retailing at around $160, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious adventurers.

The Piñon’s ideal use cases are plentiful, encompassing ultralight backpacking, minimalist camping, and even bikepacking tours. Its compact size and negligible weight make it a strong contender for adventures where every ounce matters. However, it’s not all sunshine and roses; the Piñon’s lightweight fabric, while beneficial for pack weight, may not be as durable as heavier materials, necessitating gentle handling to avoid tears or abrasions. Additionally, the bivy’s bottom is not seam-sealed, which could potentially allow minor water ingress in extremely wet conditions.

Comparing the Piñon to a notable competitor, the Outdoor Research Helium Bivy, reveals several key differences:

• The Helium is slightly heavier, at 16 ounces (453 grams), but offers fully taped seams and a more robust 30D ripstop fabric for enhanced waterproofing and durability.
• The Helium also boasts a unique HydroSeal floor construction, providing better protection from ground moisture.
• However, the Piñon excels in terms of affordability, as the Helium retails at a higher price point of around $180.
• Both bivies possess excellent ventilation features, yet the Piñon’s lighter weight and lower cost make it an attractive alternative for those willing to sacrifice a modicum of durability and waterproofing.

Best for Weather Resistance

The Outdoor Research Alpine AscentShell Bivy is a standout product in the realm of outdoor gear, particularly noted for its exceptional weather resistance. The bivy is constructed with AscentShell, a proprietary three-layer fabric that offers superior breathability and waterproofing, ensuring users stay dry and comfortable in inclement conditions. One of the standout features is its side zip, which allows for easy entry and exit, a significant advantage when quick access is needed. Additionally, the roomy hood provides ample space for movement and can accommodate a pillow for added comfort. This design ensures that users do not feel claustrophobic, a common issue with bivy sacks.

However, the Alpine AscentShell Bivy is not without its drawbacks. Some users have reported issues with condensation buildup, which can be a problem in humid environments despite the breathable fabric. Additionally, the bivy’s weight and packed size are slightly larger than some competing models, which might be a consideration for ultralight backpackers. The price point is also relatively high, which may deter budget-conscious consumers.

When comparing the Outdoor Research Alpine AscentShell Bivy to other models, it holds its own in several areas but falls short in others. For instance, the Rab Survival Zone Bivvy offers superior lightweight and packability, making it a better choice for minimalist adventurers. On the other hand, the MSR E-Bivy provides a more budget-friendly option with comparable weather resistance, although it lacks the roomy hood and side zip features. Overall, the Alpine AscentShell Bivy is a solid choice for those seeking robust weather protection and comfort, but it may not be the best fit for those prioritizing ultralight travel or budget constraints.

FAQ